Below is my column from today's edition of the Grand Haven Tribune.
This past Monday was the International Day of Transgender Visibility. As I pondered the day, I kept coming back to my own deep concerns about the rising number of attacks on the trans community.This was brought home locally when one of our local county commissioners, Joe Moss, violated the policies of Grand Valley State University by carrying a pistol on him when on campus. He was attending an anti-trans event and photos show the gun poking out of his jacket while he speaks with trans right protesters.
The most recent FBI report on hate crime saw incidents of violence due to a person’s sexual orientation increase by 23 percent – and that’s in one single year. The increases in incidents of violence related to gender identity increased as well, by 16 percent. While that’s less than the increase on people due to sexual orientation, that’s still an alarming number. For the second year in a row, more than 1 in 5 hate crimes are related to anti-LGBTQIA+ bias.
So, a known far-right conservative poorly concealing a pistol while talking to college students who are protesting in support of trans people – well, that is a disturbing photo to see. It’s particularly disturbing given attacks on the trans community that have come from Moss and other politicians aligned with him.
Sadly, the fodder for these attacks is taught in churches, where the Bible is used as justification for the exclusion and marginalization of transgender people. I’d like to try an unpack that just a bit – because so much of what people have been told is simply bad exegesis.
For example, one of the first things many Christians do when you get into conversations of gender and sexuality is they go back to the start of the Bible, in the book of Genesis, to insist that the structure of male and female in marriage was part of the way God ordained creation itself to exist.
There are so many errors to unpack here. Let’s get started.
First, what you have in Genesis 1 is what’s known as a series of merisms. This is a rhetorical device where you use two contrasting parts to refer to the whole. So, for example, instead of saying you searched everywhere for something, you might say you searched “high and low.” If you said you searched “high and low,” no one would think you didn’t search in the middle or assume only high and low existed. It’s a figure of speech.
So, God in Genesis 1, we hear about water and land, light and darkness, morning and evening, sea creatures and wingèd birds in the sky, and so on and so forth. So, when it comes to the creation of humanity, we read that “God created humankind in his image, in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them.”
But that doesn’t mean that only male and female exist within humanity any more than Genesis 1 might mean that there is only light and darkness and nothing in between.
The brilliant poet David Gate articulated this beautifully in a poem he wrote after the tragic death of Nex Benedict, a 16-year-old non-binary student who died after a year of bullying and physical violence at school. The poem goes like this:
If God created he night & the day
& the dawn, of course
& the dusk
& the tangerine rosepink sunset
& in the infant bright of morning
& the deep amethyst of twilight
Then to perceive the world in binary is to forego knowledge of the divine
I couldn’t say it better myself. And, if both male and female were created from God and in God’s image, then we are reminded, of course, that God is neither male nor female. God is a non-binary entity, the divine source of all who holds all genders within God’s being. God is the original they/them.
And when God created humanity, God made male and female and everything in between, God made people cisgender and transgender, nonbinary and genderfluid, agender and genderqueeer and intersex and bigender … God made all of these realities and expressions of gender, and just like when you look at the rich variety of daylight blending into evening, God looked at all those genders that came out of God’s own image, and God said they were very good.
So, if you are reading this and you exist somewhere on the gender spectrum beyond the cisgender identity, I want you to hear me say very clearly: God said you were very good. And never let anyone tell you otherwise.
If you want to know more about what the Bible might actually say about trans people, I encourage you to check out the resource the Human Rights Campaign put together. You can get it online at http://sjegh.com/bible&trans. You might be surprised to find there’s actually far more positive to say than you thought.
About the writer: The Rev. Dr. Jared C. Cramer, Tribune community columnist, serves as rector of St. John’s Episcopal Church in Grand Haven. Information about his parish can be found at www.sjegh.com.